Texas House Bill HB3695

Texas 2011 - 82nd Regular

• Out of House Committee: 4/27/11
• Report Pass: 4/14/11

Caption

Relating to the confidentiality of records and files related to a child who is charged with or convicted of certain misdemeanors punishable by a fine only or is found to have engaged in certain conduct indicating a need for supervision.

Impact

The legislative modifications introduced by HB 3695 are significant, as they establish clear boundaries for the disclosure of juvenile criminal records. By preventing the public dissemination of records for youth involved in minor offenses, the bill aligns with initiatives that advocate for a more privacy-focused juvenile justice system. The confidentiality measures could contribute to reduced stigma for young individuals and allow for a smoother reintegration into society following such charges or convictions.

Summary

House Bill 3695 focuses on enhancing the confidentiality of records related to children who are charged with or convicted of specific misdemeanor offenses that are punishable by a fine only. The bill specifically emphasizes the protection of such records from public disclosure during the appeal process and beyond, ensuring that they remain confidential unless certain legal stipulations are met. This aims to safeguard the privacy and future implications for young individuals facing legal issues, thereby promoting a rehabilitative rather than punitive approach.

Contention

However, this bill has sparked discussions regarding the balance between public safety and individual privacy rights. Critics may argue that while confidentiality protects minors, it could also hinder transparency within the justice system, potentially obscuring critical information from the community and law enforcement. The tension between protecting vulnerable populations and ensuring accountability within the justice process forms a central point of contention surrounding HB 3695.