Texas House Bill HCR31

Texas 2011 - 82nd Regular

• Introduced: 1/7/11
• Refer: 2/18/11

Caption

Requesting the Texas Education Agency to develop a rating system for the performance of local school boards.

Impact

If enacted, HCR31 would require the TEA to create a framework for evaluating school board performance every two years. This assessment would include measuring how personnel and financial resources are allocated toward low-performing schools. The introduction of such a system may signify a shift in how educational governance is approached in Texas, aiming for increased accountability at the board level, akin to existing measures for students, teachers, and districts. The required reporting to the legislature every even-numbered year will help maintain transparency and facilitate legislative oversight of local educational governance.

Summary

HCR31 is a concurrent resolution from the Texas Legislature requesting the Texas Education Agency (TEA) to develop a performance rating system specifically for local school boards. The resolution highlights that while Texas holds various educational entities accountable, there is currently no system in place to evaluate the effectiveness of school boards, which play a crucial role in overseeing educational programs and services within their respective districts. The proposed system aims to ensure that school boards are held responsible for their performance in relation to the educational opportunities provided to students and teachers.

Sentiment

The general sentiment surrounding HCR31 appears to be cautiously optimistic among supporters who recognize the importance of accountability in education. Advocates argue that by holding school boards accountable, the resolution can potentially lead to improved educational outcomes and resource allocation. However, some stakeholders may express concerns regarding the implementation of such a system and how effectively it can measure the true performance of school boards, considering the diverse roles and challenges they face within their districts.

Contention

Notable points of contention may arise regarding the specific metrics used to evaluate school board performance. Different stakeholders—such as educators, parents, and policymakers—may have varying opinions on what constitutes effective governance and how the performance ratings should be constructed. Additionally, the pressure of public accountability may create tension among school boards, particularly in low-performing districts that may struggle to meet the expectations outlined by the TEA. As with many educational reforms, the balance between accountability and support will be a significant aspect of the dialogue surrounding HCR31.