Texas Senate Bill SB146

Texas 2011 - 82nd Regular

• Out of Senate Committee: 5/2/11
• Voted on by Senate: 5/10/11
• Engrossed: 5/10/11
• Refer: 5/11/11

Caption

Relating to the offense of smuggling of persons and unlawful transport of an individual; providing penalties.

Impact

The enactment of SB146 would modify several existing statutes, particularly those related to kidnapping and unlawful restraint by broadening the scope of offenses associated with human smuggling. This change signifies a shift in legislative focus towards combatting human trafficking by equipping law enforcement with clearer legal provisions to address and prosecute related crimes effectively. Furthermore, the bill emphasizes the importance of appropriately categorizing offenses to ensure suitable punishments for those engaged in such illegal activities.

Summary

Senate Bill 146, introduced by Senator Hinojosa, focuses on the offense of smuggling of persons and the unlawful transport of individuals while providing specific penalties for such actions. The bill seeks to amend the Texas Penal Code to enhance the legal framework surrounding these offenses, categorizing smuggling of persons as a state jail felony while allowing for increased penalties for cases involving serious bodily injury or pecuniary benefit. Notably, if the offender is related to the transported individual within the third degree, it serves as an affirmative defense against prosecution, recognizing nuanced family dynamics in these cases.

Contention

Discussions surrounding SB146 have highlighted various concerns, particularly pertaining to the balance between rigorous enforcement of law and the potential implications on individuals' rights. Critics argue that the definitions and penalties set forth in the bill may inadvertently criminalize behaviors associated with familial bondships, especially when individuals may be assisting relatives without malicious intent. The bill’s framework must navigate these legal and ethical considerations, as well as public perception, to ensure it effectively addresses the complexities of human smuggling while upholding justice.