Texas House Bill HB1179

Texas 2013 - 83rd Regular

Caption

Relating to the payment of restitution for the taking of wildlife resources without the property owner's consent.

Impact

The legislation modifies existing statutes in the Parks and Wildlife Code by adding a specific requirement for restitution cases, thereby altering the legal landscape regarding wildlife offenses. This change is significant as it emphasizes the responsibility of offenders to restore economic balance to affected property owners. The law comes into effect only for offenses committed after its passage, ensuring that prior cases are not retroactively subjected to these new rules.

Summary

House Bill 1179 addresses the issue of restitution related to the illegal taking of wildlife resources without the consent of the property owner. The bill stipulates that courts must require defendants convicted of such offenses to compensate the landowners for their losses, reinforcing the rights of property owners. However, it explicitly excludes any restitution for the value of wildlife or wildlife remains taken, focusing solely on the economic impact of the unlawful activities on the property itself.

Contention

Notably, the bill has sparked discussions about the balance between wildlife conservation and property rights. Critics may argue that excluding wildlife value from restitution could undermine efforts to protect natural resources, potentially encouraging illegal harvesting without adequate deterrents for poachers. Conversely, supporters argue that property owners should primarily be compensated for the direct loss they suffer rather than any intangible ecological values. This point of contention highlights the ongoing debate around the stewardship of wildlife resources and property rights in Texas.