Texas 2015 - 84th Regular

Texas House Bill HB3685

Filed
 
Out of House Committee
 
Voted on by House
 
Out of Senate Committee
 
Voted on by Senate
 
Governor Action
 

Caption

Relating to the employment status of certain individuals engaged in rehabilitative work-training programs.

Impact

If enacted, HB 3685 would amend existing laws related to the sentencing of juvenile offenders, allowing for greater discretion in sentencing and increasing access to rehabilitative resources. This change is expected to lead to a significant reduction in the number of juveniles incarcerated for non-violent offenses, favoring community-based interventions that are shown to be more effective in preventing future offenses among young people. The bill also emphasizes the importance of restorative justice practices, which aim to repair the harm caused by criminal behavior through reconciliation with victims and the community.

Summary

House Bill 3685 aims to reform sentencing practices for juvenile offenders by emphasizing rehabilitation over punitive measures. This legislation seeks to address the disproportionate impact of current sentencing laws on young individuals and strives to provide alternatives that prioritize community service and rehabilitation programs. Proponents of the bill assert that such reforms are critical to ensuring that juveniles are given the opportunity to reintegrate into society rather than being trapped within a punitive system that may lead to recidivism.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding HB 3685 is largely positive among reform advocates, who view it as a necessary step towards a more equitable and just system for young offenders. Legislators and advocacy groups emphasize the bill’s potential to create a more humane approach to juvenile justice, focusing on healing rather than punishment. However, there exists some apprehension among law enforcement agencies and certain conservative legislators, who worry that reducing punitive measures could undermine public safety and accountability for juvenile crime.

Contention

Key points of contention surrounding HB 3685 revolve around the balance between accountability and rehabilitation. Detractors of the bill express concerns that it may lead to a perception of leniency towards juvenile offenders, potentially resulting in an increase in criminal behavior. Conversely, supporters argue that the current system is overly punitive and fails to recognize the developmental differences between juveniles and adults. The ongoing debate highlights the tension between traditional punitive approaches and modern rehabilitative philosophies in the juvenile justice system.

Companion Bills

TX SB1671

Identical Relating to the employment status of certain individuals engaged in rehabilitative work-training programs.

Previously Filed As

TX HB446

Relating to the terminology used in statute to refer to intellectual disability and certain references to abolished health and human services agencies.

TX SB332

Relating to the terminology used in statute to refer to intellectual disability and certain references to abolished health and human services agencies.

TX SB1539

Relating to the terminology used to refer to an individualized education program team.

TX HB272

Relating to the terminology used to refer to certain disabilities and to an individualized education team for purposes of determining a student's eligibility for special education services and providing those services in public schools.

TX HB494

Relating to employment leave for certain family or medical obligations.

TX HB1008

Relating to suspending the employment of certain persons who provide care to individuals with an intellectual or developmental disability and who are alleged to have engaged in reportable conduct; providing an administrative penalty.

TX HB3226

Relating to the development and implementation of the Live Well Texas program to provide health benefit coverage to certain individuals; imposing penalties.

TX HB4611

Relating to the nonsubstantive revision of the health and human services laws governing the Health and Human Services Commission, Medicaid, and other social services.

TX HB4902

Relating to the eligibility of certain individuals for unemployment benefits and the validity of certain claims for unemployment benefits submitted to the Texas Workforce Commission.

TX SB1847

Relating to the eligibility of certain individuals for unemployment benefits and the validity of certain claims for unemployment benefits submitted to the Texas Workforce Commission.

Similar Bills

CA SB277

Criminal procedure: search of persons.

CA AB937

Plastic products: commercial agricultural mulch film: labeling: soil biodegradable.

CA AB2632

Segregated confinement.

CA AB1464

Housing preferences.

MI SB0975

Employment security: benefits; disqualification from benefits; modify. Amends sec. 29 of 1936 (Ex Sess) PA 1 (MCL 421.29).

CA AB2564

Individual Shared Responsibility Penalty: waiver: health care service plans.

CA SB479

Termination of tenancy: no-fault just cause: natural person.

CA SB1428

Reproductive health: mifepristone and other medication.