Texas House Bill HB3035

Texas 2019 - 86th Regular

Caption

Relating to the relationship between the amount of an administrative penalty imposed by the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality and the economic benefit of the violation to the alleged violator.

Impact

The changes proposed in HB 3035 are expected to have significant implications for state environmental laws. By ensuring that penalties imposed for violations are at least equal to the economic benefit gained, the bill reinforces the principle that violating environmental standards for profit will not be cost-effective for violators. It addresses concerns from environmental advocacy groups about inadequate penalties that fail to deter noncompliance, thus promoting a more robust enforcement framework within TCEQ's regulatory scope.

Summary

House Bill 3035 aims to amend the Water Code by establishing a direct relationship between the amount of administrative penalties imposed by the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ) and any economic benefits gained through violations of environmental regulations. The bill emphasizes that penalties should be sufficiently high to serve as a deterrent against violations and to ensure that they reflect the economic gains derived from noncompliance. This shift intends to enhance accountability for various environmental offenses that could impact public health and safety as well as overall environmental quality.

Contention

While proponents of HB 3035 advocate for stricter penalties that hold violators accountable, there are points of contention regarding the balance of regulatory enforcement and the operational viability for businesses. Some critics argue that increased penalties may disproportionately affect smaller businesses or organizations with limited resources to comply with environmental regulations. The bill's stipulation allowing government entities or non-profits to defer penalty payments under certain conditions has been seen as a compromise but may raise concerns about equitable treatment among different types of violators.

Overall_significance

In a broader context, the bill reflects a heightened legislative focus on environmental sustainability and regulatory integrity. As Texas continues to face challenges related to water rights and pollution, HB 3035 represents an evolution in how the state manages environmental compliance and penalties. By aligning financial consequences more closely with the economic realities of violations, the legislature aims to foster a culture of compliance while also protecting natural resources and public health.