Utah 2023 Regular Session

Utah Senate Bill SJR007

Introduced
1/17/23  
Refer
1/17/23  
Report Pass
1/20/23  
Engrossed
2/1/23  
Report Pass
2/8/23  
Report Pass
2/8/23  

Caption

Joint Resolution Approving Settlement Agreement with the United States

Impact

The approval of SJR007 is significant as it represents an official acknowledgment by the Utah legislature of the financial obligations incurred due to alleged misuses of federal funds. By agreeing to a settlement of $1,550,000, the state seeks to mitigate further financial and legal repercussions that could arise from protracted litigation. Additionally, this resolution illustrates the state's responsibility in addressing allegations of fraud while maintaining compliance with legal requirements that necessitate legislative consent for such monetary commitments exceeding $1 million.

Summary

SJR007 is a joint resolution that serves to approve a proposed settlement agreement between the state of Utah and the United States in relation to claims made against the state concerning the use of federal grant funds. This resolution specifically addresses allegations made by Reginald Williams, a Utah Department of Corrections inmate, through a qui tam action, alleging violations under the federal False Claims Act. The proposed settlement aims to resolve claims that could potentially cost the state over $50 million in damages due to fraud assertions regarding federal grants received from 2009 to 2011.

Sentiment

The sentiment around SJR007 appears to be supportive among lawmakers, as indicated by the unanimous vote in favor (74-0) during its passage. This overwhelming support suggests a consensus on the importance of resolving the claims efficiently rather than allowing them to escalate into lengthy and costly legal battles. Legislators likely view the settlement as a pragmatic approach to safeguard the state's financial interests and ensure accountability regarding the management of federal funds.

Contention

While there seems to be a clear pathway toward approval with no recorded opposition in the voting history, the underlying allegations related to the misuse of federal funds could provoke future scrutiny. The resolution does not detail the specifics of the alleged misconduct, which might leave room for public concern or debate about the integrity of state agencies and their handling of federal resources. Nonetheless, in the immediate context, SJR007 stands as a resolution born from legal necessity aimed at limiting the fallout from past actions.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Similar Bills

PA SB1051

In corporate net income tax, further providing for definitions; in procedure and administration, further providing for petition for reassessment and for review by board and providing for settlement conference process, for closing agreements and for report to General Assembly; and, in general provisions, further providing for timely filing.

PA HB1994

In corporate net income tax, further providing for definitions; in procedure and administration, further providing for petition for reassessment and for review by board and providing for settlement conference process, for closing agreements and for report to General Assembly; and, in general provisions, further providing for timely filing.

CA AB1405

Debt settlement practices.

CA AB2810

Opioid Settlements Fund.

CA SB1105

Civil actions: settlement.

MI SB0592

Civil procedure: civil actions; civil actions against certain opioid litigation settlement defendants; prohibit. Amends secs. 2 & 3 of 2022 PA 85 (MCL 691.1672 & 691.1673).

CA AB2366

Sales and use tax: administration: settlements.

CA AB1166

Fair Debt Settlement Practices Act.