Wisconsin 2023-2024 Regular Session

Wisconsin Senate Bill SB933

Introduced
1/19/24  
Refer
1/19/24  
Report Pass
2/13/24  
Engrossed
2/20/24  
Refer
2/20/24  
Enrolled
2/27/24  
Vetoed
3/29/24  

Caption

Prohibiting discrimination in organ transplantation and donation on the basis of an individual's vaccination status.

Impact

If enacted, SB933 would amend existing laws that provide safeguards for individuals with disabilities by extending similar protections to those based on vaccination status. This regulatory change would ensure that individuals are not denied critical healthcare services or placed at a disadvantage in organ transplantation and donation processes due to their vaccination choices. Given the current socio-political climate surrounding vaccinations, the bill seeks to balance public health interests with personal freedoms, reflecting ongoing debates about individual rights in medical decision-making.

Summary

Senate Bill 933 is a legislative proposal aimed at prohibiting discrimination in organ transplantation and donation based on an individual's vaccination status. The bill explicitly prevents hospitals and transplant hospitals from denying an individual any services related to organ transplantation solely based on their vaccination status. This includes actions such as ineligibility for receiving an anatomical gift, denial of referral to transplant specialists, and placement on less favorable positions on organ transplant waiting lists due to vaccination status. The definition of 'vaccination status' encompasses individuals who have either received or not received vaccines authorized by the federal Food and Drug Administration for various reasons, including health or personal beliefs.

Contention

The proposed legislation has sparked considerable debate among stakeholders. Supporters argue that it is vital to uphold the rights of individuals with differing vaccination views, ensuring they are treated equally in critical healthcare situations. Conversely, opponents may contend that the bill could impede healthcare providers' ability to make decisions that prioritize patient safety and public health. The separation between individual choices and collective health responsibilities remains a contentious point and has potential implications for the healthcare system's operation, particularly in transplant scenarios where urgency and compatibility are critical.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

WI AB955

Prohibiting discrimination in organ transplantation and donation on the basis of an individual's vaccination status.

WI S644

No CV19 Discrimination/Organ Transplantation

WI HB4076

Relating to prohibiting organ transplant recipient discrimination on the basis of vaccination status.

WI HB1129

Prohibit forms of discrimination in access to organ transplantation.

WI HB3032

Prohibiting discrimination based on an individual’s mental or physical disability in access to organ transplantation

WI SB647

Prohibiting discrimination in organ donation process

WI HB96

Public Health - Nondiscrimination in Access to Anatomical Gifts and Organ Transplantation - Financial Status

WI SB71

Organ Donation Discrimination

WI HB253

Prohibits discriminatory practices on the basis of vaccination status or immunity status

WI LD1055

An Act to Prohibit Discrimination in Access to Anatomical Donations and Organ Transplants

Similar Bills

NJ A3919

Protects patients waiting for organ transplants from certain discriminatory actions based on vaccination status.

WI AB955

Prohibiting discrimination in organ transplantation and donation on the basis of an individual's vaccination status.

TX HB473

Relating to prohibiting organ transplant recipient discrimination on the basis of certain disabilities.

TX HB119

Relating to prohibiting organ transplant recipient discrimination on the basis of certain disabilities.

TX SB1017

Relating to prohibiting organ transplant recipient discrimination on the basis of certain disabilities.

ME LD1055

An Act to Prohibit Discrimination in Access to Anatomical Donations and Organ Transplants

AL SB208

Relating to health care; to prohibit discrimination against an individual with a disability in receiving an anatomical gift or organ transplant based on his or her disability; and to require health care providers and organ transplant centers to provide reasonable accommodations to individuals with a disability in medical need of an anatomical gift or organ transplant.

AL HB122

Relating to health care; to prohibit discrimination against an individual with a disability in receiving an anatomical gift or organ transplant based on his or her disability; to require health care providers and organ transplant centers to provide reasonable accommodations to individuals with a disability in medical need of an anatomical gift or organ transplant; and to provide disabled individuals the right to equitable relief.