Alabama 2024 Regular Session

Alabama House Bill HB164 Compare Versions

OldNewDifferences
1-HB164ENROLLED
1+HB164ENGROSSED
22 Page 0
33 HB164
4-25GWSSK-3
4+25GWSSK-2
55 By Representatives Robbins, DuBose, Faulkner
66 RFD: Judiciary
77 First Read: 14-Feb-24
88 1
99 2
1010 3
1111 4
12-5 HB164 Enrolled
12+5 HB164 Engrossed
1313 Page 1
1414 First Read: 14-Feb-24
15-Enrolled, An Act,
16-Relating to consumer protection; to provide
17-legislative findings; to provide definitions; to provide
18-age-verification requirements for the distribution of sexual
19-material harmful to minors through certain adult websites,
20-applications, and digital and virtual platforms; to prohibit
21-the retention of certain personally identifying information;
22-to assess an additional tax on the gross proceeds received
23-through sales, distribution, memberships, subscriptions, and
24-performances of material deemed harmful to minors; to require
25-notice to be given of the dangers of pornography under certain
26-conditions; to provide civil and criminal penalties for
27-violations; to amend Section 13A-6-240, Code of Alabama 1975,
28-as amended by Act 2023-464, 2023 Regular Session, to require
29-written consent to distribute a private image of another, with
30-exceptions; and to further provide for the enforcement
31-authority of the Attorney General; and in connection therewith
32-would have as its purpose or effect the requirement of a new
33-or increased expenditure of local funds within the meaning of
34-Section 111.05 of the Constitution of Alabama of 2022.
35-BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF ALABAMA:
36-Section 1. The Legislature finds and declares the
37-following:
38-(1) The pervasive use of pornography is creating a
39-public health crisis.
40-(2) Pornography is contributing to the
41-hypersexualization of children and teens in our society.
15+A BILL
16+TO BE ENTITLED
17+AN ACT
18+Relating to consumer protection; to provide legislative
19+findings; to provide definitions; to provide age-verification
20+requirements for the distribution of sexual material harmful
21+to minors through certain adult websites, applications, and
22+digital and virtual platforms; to prohibit the retention of
23+certain personally identifying information; to assess an
24+additional tax on the gross proceeds received through sales,
25+distribution, memberships, subscriptions, and performances of
26+material deemed harmful to minors; to require notice to be
27+given of the dangers of pornography under certain conditions;
28+to provide civil and criminal penalties for violations; to
29+amend Section 13A-6-240, Code of Alabama 1975, as amended by
30+Act 2023-464, 2023 Regular Session, to require written consent
31+to distribute a private image of another, with exceptions; and
32+to further provide for the enforcement authority of the
33+Attorney General; and in connection therewith would have as
34+its purpose or effect the requirement of a new or increased
35+expenditure of local funds within the meaning of Section
36+111.05 of the Constitution of Alabama of 2022.
4237 1
4338 2
4439 3
4540 4
4641 5
4742 6
4843 7
4944 8
5045 9
5146 10
5247 11
5348 12
5449 13
5550 14
5651 15
5752 16
5853 17
5954 18
6055 19
6156 20
6257 21
6358 22
6459 23
6560 24
6661 25
6762 26
6863 27
69-28 HB164 Enrolled
64+28 HB164 Engrossed
7065 Page 2
66+111.05 of the Constitution of Alabama of 2022.
67+BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF ALABAMA:
68+Section 1. The Legislature finds and declares the
69+following:
70+(1) The pervasive use of pornography is creating a
71+public health crisis.
72+(2) Pornography is contributing to the
7173 hypersexualization of children and teens in our society.
7274 (3) Due to advances in technology and the universal
7375 availability of the Internet, young children are more easily
7476 exposed to pornography than ever before, with the average age
7577 of exposure now being only 11 to 12 years of age.
7678 (4) Pornography treats people as objects and
7779 commodities for the viewer's use.
7880 (5) Pornography normalizes violence and abuse, often
7981 depicts rape and abuse as being harmless fun, and increases
8082 the demand for sex trafficking, prostitution, and child
8183 pornography.
8284 (6) Pornography is a public health crisis leading to a
8385 broad spectrum of individual and public health impacts and
8486 societal harms. This state has a compelling governmental
8587 interest to take action, and this act serves as the most
8688 narrowly tailored approach to prevent pornography exposure and
8789 addiction to minors and to educate individuals and families
8890 concerning its very serious harms.
8991 Section 2. As used in Sections 1 through 14 of this
9092 act, the following terms have the following meanings:
9193 (1) ADULT WEBSITE. A website, application, or digital
9294 or virtual platform that uses the Internet to facilitate the
93-dissemination of pictures, videos, or other content, a
94-substantial portion of which is sexual material harmful to
95-minors.
96-(2) COMMERCIAL ENTITY. The term includes corporations,
97-limited liability companies, partnerships, limited
98-partnerships, sole proprietorships, or other legally
99-recognized entities.
10095 29
10196 30
10297 31
10398 32
10499 33
105100 34
106101 35
107102 36
108103 37
109104 38
110105 39
111106 40
112107 41
113108 42
114109 43
115110 44
116111 45
117112 46
118113 47
119114 48
120115 49
121116 50
122117 51
123118 52
124119 53
125120 54
126121 55
127-56 HB164 Enrolled
122+56 HB164 Engrossed
128123 Page 3
124+or virtual platform that uses the Internet to facilitate the
125+dissemination of pictures, videos, or other content, a
126+substantial portion of which is sexual material harmful to
127+minors.
128+(2) COMMERCIAL ENTITY. The term includes corporations,
129+limited liability companies, partnerships, limited
130+partnerships, sole proprietorships, or other legally
129131 recognized entities.
130132 (3) CONSUMER INTEREST DIVISION. The Consumer Interest
131133 Division of the Office of the Attorney General.
132134 (4) DISTRIBUTE. To issue, sell, give, provide, deliver,
133135 transfer, circulate, or disseminate.
134136 (5) HARMFUL TO MINORS. The term as defined under
135137 Section 13A-12-200.1, Code of Alabama 1975.
136138 (6) MINOR. An individual under 18 years of age.
137139 (7) NEWS-GATHERING ORGANIZATION. Any of the following:
138140 a. A newspaper, news publication, or other news source,
139141 whether in printed or electronic format, of current news and
140142 public interest.
141143 b. A radio broadcast station, television broadcast
142144 station, or cable television operator.
143145 (8) PUBLISH. To communicate or make information
144146 available to another person through an online platform.
145147 (9) REASONABLE AGE-VERIFICATION METHOD. Any
146148 commercially available software, application, program, or
147149 methodology that, when enabled, provides reasonable assurances
148150 that any individual accessing certain published material is 18
149151 years of age or older.
150152 (10) SUBSTANTIAL PORTION. More than 33 1/3 percent.
151-Section 3. (a) Any commercial entity that knowingly and
152-intentionally publishes or distributes sexual material harmful
153-to minors through an adult website shall use a reasonable
154-age-verification method to provide reasonable assurance that
155-individuals under 18 years of age cannot access the material
156-harmful to minors.
157-(b) Nothing in this section shall apply to a bona fide
158153 57
159154 58
160155 59
161156 60
162157 61
163158 62
164159 63
165160 64
166161 65
167162 66
168163 67
169164 68
170165 69
171166 70
172167 71
173168 72
174169 73
175170 74
176171 75
177172 76
178173 77
179174 78
180175 79
181176 80
182177 81
183178 82
184179 83
185-84 HB164 Enrolled
180+84 HB164 Engrossed
186181 Page 4
182+(10) SUBSTANTIAL PORTION. More than 33 1/3 percent.
183+Section 3. (a) Any commercial entity that knowingly and
184+intentionally publishes or distributes sexual material harmful
185+to minors through an adult website shall use a reasonable
186+age-verification method to provide reasonable assurance that
187+individuals under 18 years of age cannot access the material
188+harmful to minors.
187189 (b) Nothing in this section shall apply to a bona fide
188190 news-gathering organization.
189191 Section 4. (a) Any commercial entity or third party
190192 that performs the required age-verification under Section 3
191193 shall not retain any personally identifying information of the
192194 individual after access has been granted to the sexual
193195 material.
194196 (b) A commercial entity that is found to have knowingly
195197 retained identifying information of the individual, as
196198 prohibited in subsection (a), shall be liable to the
197199 individual for damages resulting from retaining the
198200 identifying information, including court costs and reasonable
199201 attorney fees as ordered by the court.
200202 (c) Nothing in this section shall apply to a bona fide
201203 news-gathering organization.
202204 Section 5. No Internet service provider, or its
203205 affiliates or subsidiaries, search engine, or cloud service
204206 provider shall be held to have violated Sections 1 through 10
205207 of this act or Section 13A-6-240, Code of Alabama 1975, solely
206208 for providing access or connection to or from a website or
207209 other information or content on the Internet or a facility,
208210 system, or network not under that provider's control,
209-including transmission, downloading, intermediate storage, or
210-access software to the extent the provider is not responsible
211-for the creation of the content of the communication that
212-constitutes sexual material harmful to minors.
213-Section 6. (a) Any individual injured by a violation of
214-Section 3, Section 8, or Section 9 may bring a civil action in
215-circuit court against the commercial entity to recover actual
216211 85
217212 86
218213 87
219214 88
220215 89
221216 90
222217 91
223218 92
224219 93
225220 94
226221 95
227222 96
228223 97
229224 98
230225 99
231226 100
232227 101
233228 102
234229 103
235230 104
236231 105
237232 106
238233 107
239234 108
240235 109
241236 110
242237 111
243-112 HB164 Enrolled
238+112 HB164 Engrossed
244239 Page 5
245-circuit court against the commercial entity to recover actual
246-and punitive damages, court costs, and reasonable attorney's
247-fees. If the injured individual is a minor, then a parent or
248-legal guardian may bring action on his or her behalf.
240+system, or network not under that provider's control,
241+including transmission, downloading, intermediate storage, or
242+access software to the extent the provider is not responsible
243+for the creation of the content of the communication that
244+constitutes sexual material harmful to minors.
245+Section 6. (a) Any individual injured by a violation of
246+Section 3, Section 8, or Section 9 may bring a civil action
247+against the commercial entity to recover actual and punitive
248+damages, court costs, and reasonable attorney's fees. If the
249+injured individual is a minor, then a parent or legal guardian
250+may bring action on his or her behalf.
249251 (b) Upon commencement of any action brought under this
250-section, the plaintiff shall mail a copy of the complaint or
251-other initial pleading to the Attorney General and upon entry
252-of any judgment or decree in the action, shall mail a copy of
253-the judgment or decree to the Attorney General.
252+section, the clerk of the court shall mail a copy of the
253+complaint or other initial pleading to the Attorney General
254+and upon entry of any judgment or decree in the action, shall
255+mail a copy of the judgment or decree to the Attorney General.
254256 (c) Upon a finding by the court that a violation of
255257 Section 3, Section 8, or Section 9 has occurred, the Attorney
256258 General, upon petition to the court, may recover a civil
257259 penalty up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000) per violation.
258260 Section 7. In addition to any other penalty provided by
259261 law, any violation of Section 3, Section 8, or Section 9 shall
260262 be considered a violation of the Deceptive Trade Practices Act
261263 under Chapter 19 of Title 8, Code of Alabama 1975.
262264 Section 8. (a) Any commercial entity, before knowingly
263265 and intentionally publishing or distributing a private image,
264266 as defined under Section 13A-6-240, Code of Alabama 1975,
265267 through an adult website, shall obtain written consent to
266268 publish or distribute the private image from every individual
267-depicted in the private image.
268-(b) The written consent required by this section shall
269-be signed by the individual depicted and sworn to by a notary
270-public. The commercial entity shall maintain records of the
271-written consent for not less than five calendar years
272-following the publication or distribution of the private
273-image.
274269 113
275270 114
276271 115
277272 116
278273 117
279274 118
280275 119
281276 120
282277 121
283278 122
284279 123
285280 124
286281 125
287282 126
288283 127
289284 128
290285 129
291286 130
292287 131
293288 132
294289 133
295290 134
296291 135
297292 136
298293 137
299294 138
300295 139
301-140 HB164 Enrolled
296+140 HB164 Engrossed
302297 Page 6
298+publish or distribute the private image from every individual
299+depicted in the private image.
300+(b) The written consent required by this section shall
301+be signed by the individual depicted and sworn to by a notary
302+public. The commercial entity shall maintain records of the
303+written consent for not less than five calendar years
304+following the publication or distribution of the private
303305 image.
304306 Section 9. (a) A commercial entity required to use
305307 reasonable age verification methods under Section 3 shall do
306308 all of the following:
307309 (1) Display the following notices on the home or
308310 landing page of the adult website on which sexual material
309311 harmful to minors is published or distributed and all
310312 advertisements thereof:
311313 "ALABAMA HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES WARNING: Pornography
312314 is potentially biologically addictive, is proven to harm human
313315 brain development, desensitizes brain reward circuits,
314316 increases conditioned responses, and weakens brain function."
315317 "ALABAMA HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES WARNING: Exposure to
316318 this content is associated with low self-esteem and body
317319 image, eating disorders, impaired brain development, and other
318320 emotional and mental illnesses."
319321 "ALABAMA HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES WARNING: Pornography
320322 increases the demand for prostitution, child exploitation, and
321323 child pornography."
322324 (2) Display the following notice on every page of the
323325 adult website:
324326 "U.S. SUBSTANCE ABUSE AND MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES
325-ADMINISTRATION HELPLINE:
326-"1-800-662-HELP (4357)
327-"THIS HELPLINE IS A FREE, CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION
328-SERVICE (IN ENGLISH OR SPANISH) OPEN 24 HOURS PER DAY, FOR
329-INDIVIDUALS AND FAMILY MEMBERS FACING MENTAL HEALTH OR
330-SUBSTANCE USE DISORDERS. THE SERVICE PROVIDES REFERRAL TO
331-LOCAL TREATMENT FACILITIES, SUPPORT GROUPS, AND
332327 141
333328 142
334329 143
335330 144
336331 145
337332 146
338333 147
339334 148
340335 149
341336 150
342337 151
343338 152
344339 153
345340 154
346341 155
347342 156
348343 157
349344 158
350345 159
351346 160
352347 161
353348 162
354349 163
355350 164
356351 165
357352 166
358353 167
359-168 HB164 Enrolled
354+168 HB164 Engrossed
360355 Page 7
356+"U.S. SUBSTANCE ABUSE AND MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES
357+ADMINISTRATION HELPLINE:
358+"1-800-662-HELP (4357)
359+"THIS HELPLINE IS A FREE, CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION
360+SERVICE (IN ENGLISH OR SPANISH) OPEN 24 HOURS PER DAY, FOR
361+INDIVIDUALS AND FAMILY MEMBERS FACING MENTAL HEALTH OR
362+SUBSTANCE USE DISORDERS. THE SERVICE PROVIDES REFERRAL TO
361363 LOCAL TREATMENT FACILITIES, SUPPORT GROUPS, AND
362364 COMMUNITY-BASED ORGANIZATIONS."
363365 (b) A violation of this section shall be punished as
364366 provided under Section 6 or Section 7.
365367 (c) Each notice required under this section shall be
366368 displayed in 14 point font or greater and in a conspicuous
367369 manner.
368370 Section 10. (a) In addition to all other taxes of
369371 every kind, there is levied and shall be collected a tax at
370372 the rate of 10 percent upon the gross receipts of any
371373 commercial entity operating an adult website for all sales,
372374 distributions, memberships, subscriptions, performances, and
373375 all other content amounting to material harmful to minors that
374376 is produced, sold, filmed, generated, or otherwise based in
375377 this state.
376378 (b) The tax levied by this section shall be collected
377379 by the State Department of Revenue at the same time and in the
378380 same manner as state sales and use taxes are collected. On or
379381 prior to the date the tax is due, each person subject to the
380382 tax shall file with the department a report in the form
381383 prescribed by the department.
382384 (c) Any taxes collected under this section shall be
383-budgeted and allotted in accordance with Sections 41-4-80
384-through 41-4-96, Code of Alabama 1975, and Sections 41-19-1
385-through 41-19-12, Code of Alabama 1975, and shall be
386-distributed to the Department of Mental Health for the care
387-and treatment of individuals with behavioral health needs,
388-including prevention, treatment, and recovery services and
389-supports.
390385 169
391386 170
392387 171
393388 172
394389 173
395390 174
396391 175
397392 176
398393 177
399394 178
400395 179
401396 180
402397 181
403398 182
404399 183
405400 184
406401 185
407402 186
408403 187
409404 188
410405 189
411406 190
412407 191
413408 192
414409 193
415410 194
416411 195
417-196 HB164 Enrolled
412+196 HB164 Engrossed
418413 Page 8
414+(c) Any taxes collected under this section shall be
415+budgeted and allotted in accordance with Sections 41-4-80
416+through 41-4-96, Code of Alabama 1975, and Sections 41-19-1
417+through 41-19-12, Code of Alabama 1975, and shall be
418+distributed to the Department of Mental Health for the care
419+and treatment of individuals with behavioral health needs,
420+including prevention, treatment, and recovery services and
419421 supports.
420422 Section 11. Section 13A-6-240, Code of Alabama 1975, as
421423 amended by Act 2023-464, 2023 Regular Session, is amended to
422424 read as follows:
423425 "ยง13A-6-240
424426 (a) A person commits the crime of distributing a
425427 private image if he or she knowingly posts, emails, texts,
426428 transmits, or otherwise distributes a private image when the
427429 depicted person individual has not consented in writing to the
428430 transmission and the depicted person individual had a
429431 reasonable expectation of privacy against transmission of the
430432 private image.
431433 (b) For purposes of this section, "private image" means
432434 a photograph, digital image, video, film, or other recording
433435 of a person an individual who is identifiable from the
434436 recording itself or from the circumstances of its transmission
435437 and who is engaged in any act of
436438 sadomasochisticsado-masochistic abuse, sexual intercourse,
437439 sexual excitement, masturbation, breast nudity, as defined in
438440 Section 13A-12-190, genital nudity, or other sexual conduct ,
439441 as those terms are defined under Section 13A-12-190 . The term
440442 includes a recording that has been edited, altered, or
441-otherwise manipulated from its original form.
442-(c)(1) For purposes of this section, a "reasonable
443-expectation of privacy" includes, but is not limited to,
444-either of the following circumstances:
445-a. The person individual depicted in the private image
446-created it or consented to its creation believing that it
447-would remain confidential.
448443 197
449444 198
450445 199
451446 200
452447 201
453448 202
454449 203
455450 204
456451 205
457452 206
458453 207
459454 208
460455 209
461456 210
462457 211
463458 212
464459 213
465460 214
466461 215
467462 216
468463 217
469464 218
470465 219
471466 220
472467 221
473468 222
474469 223
475-224 HB164 Enrolled
470+224 HB164 Engrossed
476471 Page 9
472+includes a recording that has been edited, altered, or
473+otherwise manipulated from its original form.
474+(c)(1) For purposes of this section, a "reasonable
475+expectation of privacy" includes, but is not limited to,
476+either of the following circumstances:
477+a. The person individual depicted in the private image
478+created it or consented to its creation believing that it
477479 would remain confidential.
478480 b. The sexual conduct depicted in the image was
479481 involuntary.
480482 (2) There is no reasonable expectation of privacy
481483 against the transmission of a private image made voluntarily
482484 in a public setting or made with prior written consent in a
483485 commercial setting.
484486 (d) It is a defense to distributing a private image if
485487 the distribution of the private image was made in the public
486488 interest, including, but not limited to, the reporting of
487489 unlawful conduct; the lawful and common practices of law
488490 enforcement, legal proceedings, or medical treatment; or a
489491 bona fide attempt to prevent further distribution of the
490492 private image.
491493 (e) For the purposes of determining jurisdiction, the
492494 crime of distributing a private image shall be considered to
493495 be committed in any county in which any part of the crime took
494496 place, in the county of residence of the victim or defendant,
495497 or any county where the image is received.
496498 (f) A violation of this section is a Class A
497499 misdemeanor. A subsequent adjudication or conviction under
498500 this section is a Class C felony.
499-(g) If the Attorney General has reason to believe a
500-person has engaged in, or is engaging in, a violation of this
501-section, the Attorney General may petition for an emergency
502-injunction or other necessary relief to enjoin the violation,
503-and may order the person to provide a copy of the written
504-consent required by this section.
505-(h) No Internet service provider, or its affiliates or
506501 225
507502 226
508503 227
509504 228
510505 229
511506 230
512507 231
513508 232
514509 233
515510 234
516511 235
517512 236
518513 237
519514 238
520515 239
521516 240
522517 241
523518 242
524519 243
525520 244
526521 245
527522 246
528523 247
529524 248
530525 249
531526 250
532527 251
533-252 HB164 Enrolled
528+252 HB164 Engrossed
534529 Page 10
530+this section is a Class C felony.
531+(g) If the Attorney General has reason to believe a
532+person has engaged in, or is engaging in, a violation of this
533+section, the Attorney General may petition for an emergency
534+injunction or other necessary relief to enjoin the violation,
535+and may order the person to provide a copy of the written
536+consent required by this section.
535537 (h) No Internet service provider, or its affiliates or
536538 subsidiaries, search engine, or cloud service provider shall
537539 be held to have violated this section solely for providing
538540 access or connection to or from a website or other information
539541 or content on the Internet or a facility, system, or network
540542 not under that provider's control, including transmission,
541543 downloading, intermediate storage, or access software to the
542544 extent the provider is not responsible for the creation of the
543545 content of the communication that constitutes a private
544546 image."
545547 Section 12. Although this bill would have as its
546548 purpose or effect the requirement of a new or increased
547549 expenditure of local funds, the bill is excluded from further
548550 requirements and application under Section 111.05 of the
549551 Constitution of Alabama of 2022, because the bill defines a
550552 new crime or amends the definition of an existing crime.
551553 Section 13. The Department of Revenue may adopt rules
552554 for the implementation and administration of Sections 1
553555 through 10 of this act.
554556 Section 14. Section 10 of this act shall become
555557 effective September 1, 2025; the remaining sections of this
556558 act shall become effective on October 1, 2024.
557559 253
558560 254
559561 255
560562 256
561563 257
562564 258
563565 259
564566 260
565567 261
566568 262
567569 263
568570 264
569571 265
570572 266
571573 267
572574 268
573575 269
574576 270
575577 271
576578 272
577-273 HB164 Enrolled
578-Page 11
579-act shall become effective on October 1, 2024.
580-________________________________________________
581-Speaker of the House of Representatives
582-________________________________________________
583-President and Presiding Officer of the Senate
584-House of Representatives
585-I hereby certify that the within Act originated in and
586-was passed by the House 29-Feb-24, as amended.
587-John Treadwell
588-Clerk
589-Senate 09-Apr-24 Amended and Passed
590-House 11-Apr-24 Concurred in Senate
591-Amendment
579+273
592580 274
593581 275
594582 276
595583 277
596584 278
597585 279
598-280
586+280 HB164 Engrossed
587+Page 11
588+act shall become effective on October 1, 2024.
589+House of Representatives
590+Read for the first time and referred
591+to the House of Representatives
592+committee on Judiciary
593+................14-Feb-24
594+Read for the second time and placed
595+on the calendar:
596+ 4 amendments
597+................21-Feb-24
598+Read for the third time and passed
599+as amended
600+Yeas 101
601+Nays 1
602+Abstains 0
603+................29-Feb-24
604+John Treadwell
605+Clerk
599606 281
600607 282
601608 283
602609 284
603610 285
604611 286
605612 287
606613 288
607614 289
608615 290
609616 291
610617 292
611618 293
612619 294
613620 295
614621 296
615622 297
616623 298
617624 299
618625 300
619626 301
620-302
621-303
622-304
623-305
624-306