Connecticut 2019 Regular Session

Connecticut House Bill HB07245 Latest Draft

Bill / Comm Sub Version Filed 05/16/2019

                             
 
LCO    \\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2019HB-07245-R02-
HB.docx  
1 of 13 
 
General Assembly  Substitute Bill No. 7245  
January Session, 2019 
 
 
 
 
 
AN ACT CONCERNING AD VANCE ENROLLMENT OF STUDENTS IN 
CHARTER SCHOOLS AND INTERDISTRICT MAGNET SCHOOLS BY 
MEMBERS OF THE ARMED FORCES.  
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives in General 
Assembly convened: 
 
Section 1. Section 10-66bb of the general statutes is repealed and the 1 
following is substituted in lieu thereof (Effective October 1, 2019): 2 
(a) (1) On and after July 1, 1997, and prior to July 1, 2015, the State 3 
Board of Education may grant charters for local and state charter 4 
schools in accordance with this section. On and after July 1, 2015, such 5 
state board may grant initial certificates of approval for charters for 6 
local and state charter schools in accordance with this section. Upon 7 
granting an initial certificate of approval for a charter, such state board 8 
shall submit a copy of the initial certificate of approval for the charter 9 
and a summary of the comments made at a public hearing conducted 10 
pursuant to subdivision (2) of subsection (e) of this section or 11 
subparagraph (B)(ii) of subdivision (1) of subsection (f) of this section, 12 
in accordance with section 11-4a, to the joint standing committees of 13 
the General Assembly having cognizance of matters relating to 14 
education and appropriations and the budgets of state agencies.  15 
(2) The General Assembly may appropriate funds to the Department 16 
of Education for the purposes of providing grants to local and state 17 
charter schools, pursuant to section 10-66ee. If such funds are 18  Substitute Bill No. 7245 
 
 
LCO    {\\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2019HB-07245-
R02-HB.docx }   
2 of 13 
 
appropriated, an initial certificate of approval for a charter for a local 19 
or state charter school shall be effective and deemed a charter as of July 20 
first of the first fiscal year for which such funds are appropriated. 21 
(3) A charter or initial certificate of approval for a charter granted 22 
under this section shall not be considered a license, as defined in 23 
section 4-166, for the purposes of chapter 54. 24 
(b) Any not-for-profit organization that is exempt from taxation 25 
under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, or any 26 
subsequent corresponding internal revenue code of the United States, 27 
as amended from time to time, public or independent institution of 28 
higher education, local or regional board of education or two or more 29 
boards of education cooperatively, or regional educational service 30 
center may apply to the Commissioner of Education, at such time and 31 
in such manner as the commissioner prescribes, to obtain an initial 32 
certificate of approval for a charter, provided no nonpublic elementary 33 
or secondary school may be established as a charter school and no 34 
parent or group of parents providing home instruction may establish a 35 
charter school for such instruction. 36 
(c) On and after July 1, 2015, the State Board of Education shall 37 
review, annually, all applications and grant initial certificates of 38 
approval for charters, in accordance with subsections (e) and (f) of this 39 
section, for a local or state charter school located in a town that has one 40 
or more schools that have been designated as a commissioner's 41 
network school, pursuant to section 10-223h, at the time of such 42 
application, or a town that has been designated as a low achieving 43 
school district, pursuant to section 10-223e, at the time of such 44 
application. (1) Except as provided for in subdivision (2) of this 45 
subsection, no state charter school shall enroll (A) (i) more than two 46 
hundred fifty students, or (ii) in the case of a kindergarten to grade 47 
eight, inclusive, school, more than three hundred students, or (B) 48 
twenty-five per cent of the enrollment of the school district in which 49 
the state charter school is to be located, whichever is less. (2) In the 50 
case of a state charter school found by the State Board of Education to 51  Substitute Bill No. 7245 
 
 
LCO    {\\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2019HB-07245-
R02-HB.docx }   
3 of 13 
 
have a demonstrated record of achievement, said board shall, upon 52 
application by such school to said board, waive the provisions of 53 
subdivision (1) of this subsection for such school. (3) The State Board of 54 
Education shall give preference to applicants for charter schools (A) 55 
whose primary purpose is the establishment of education programs 56 
designed to serve one or more of the following student populations: (i) 57 
Students with a history of low academic performance, (ii) students 58 
who receive free or reduced priced lunches pursuant to federal law 59 
and regulations, (iii) students with a history of behavioral and social 60 
difficulties, (iv) students identified as requiring special education, (v) 61 
students who are English language learners, or (vi) students of a single 62 
gender; (B) whose primary purpose is to improve the academic 63 
performance of an existing school that has consistently demonstrated 64 
substandard academic performance, as determined by the 65 
Commissioner of Education; (C) that will serve students who reside in 66 
a priority school district pursuant to section 10-266p; (D) that will serve 67 
students who reside in a district in which seventy-five per cent or more 68 
of the enrolled students are members of racial or ethnic minorities; (E) 69 
that demonstrate highly credible and specific strategies to attract, 70 
enroll and retain students from among the populations described in 71 
subparagraph (A)(i) to (A)(vi), inclusive, of this subdivision; or (F) that, 72 
in the case of an applicant for a state charter school, such state charter 73 
school will be located at a work-site or such applicant is an institution 74 
of higher education. In determining whether to grant an initial 75 
certificate of approval for a charter, the State Board of Education shall 76 
consider (i) the effect of the proposed charter school on (I) the 77 
reduction of racial, ethnic and economic isolation in the region in 78 
which it is to be located, (II) the regional distribution of charter schools 79 
in the state, (III) the potential of over-concentration of charter schools 80 
within a school district or in contiguous school districts, and (IV) the 81 
state's efforts to close achievement gaps, as defined in section 10-16oo, 82 
and (ii) the comments made at a public hearing conducted pursuant to 83 
subdivision (2) of subsection (e) of this section or subparagraph (B)(ii) 84 
of subdivision (1) of subsection (f) of this section. 85  Substitute Bill No. 7245 
 
 
LCO    {\\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2019HB-07245-
R02-HB.docx }   
4 of 13 
 
(d) Applications pursuant to this section shall include a description 86 
of: (1) The mission, purpose and any specialized focus of the proposed 87 
charter school; (2) the interest in the community for the establishment 88 
of the charter school; (3) the school governance and procedures for the 89 
establishment of a governing council that (A) includes (i) teachers and 90 
parents and guardians of students enrolled in the school, and (ii) the 91 
chairperson of the local or regional board of education of the town in 92 
which the charter school is located and which has jurisdiction over a 93 
school that resembles the approximate grade configuration of the 94 
charter school, or the designee of such chairperson, provided such 95 
designee is a member of the board of education or the superintendent 96 
of schools for the school district, or the superintendent's designee, and 97 
(B) is responsible for the oversight of charter school operations, 98 
provided no member or employee of the governing council may have a 99 
personal or financial interest in the assets, real or personal, of the 100 
school; (4) the financial plan for operation of the school, provided no 101 
application fees or other fees for attendance, except as provided in this 102 
section, may be charged; (5) the educational program, instructional 103 
methodology and services to be offered to students; (6) the number 104 
and qualifications of teachers and administrators to be employed in the 105 
school; (7) the organization of the school in terms of the ages or grades 106 
to be taught and the total estimated enrollment of the school; (8) the 107 
student admission criteria and procedures to (A) ensure effective 108 
public information, (B) ensure open access on a space available basis, 109 
including the enrollment of students during the school year if spaces 110 
become available in the charter school, (C) promote a diverse student 111 
body, and (D) ensure that the school complies with the provisions of 112 
section 10-15c and that it does not discriminate on the basis of 113 
disability, athletic performance or proficiency in the English language, 114 
provided the school may limit enrollment to a particular grade level or 115 
specialized educational focus and, if there is not space available for all 116 
students seeking enrollment, the school may give preference to siblings 117 
but shall otherwise determine enrollment by a lottery, except the State 118 
Board of Education may waive the requirements for such enrollment 119 
lottery pursuant to subsection [(j)] (k) of this section; (9) a means to 120  Substitute Bill No. 7245 
 
 
LCO    {\\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2019HB-07245-
R02-HB.docx }   
5 of 13 
 
assess student performance that includes participation in mastery 121 
examinations, pursuant to section 10-14n; (10) procedures for teacher 122 
evaluation and professional development for teachers and 123 
administrators; (11) the provision of school facilities, pupil 124 
transportation and student health and welfare services; (12) 125 
procedures to encourage involvement by parents and guardians of 126 
enrolled students in student learning, school activities and school 127 
decision-making; (13) procedures to document efforts to increase the 128 
racial and ethnic diversity of staff; (14) a five-year plan to sustain the 129 
maintenance and operation of the school; (15) a student recruitment 130 
and retention plan that shall include, but not be limited to, a clear 131 
description of a plan and the capacity of the school to attract, enroll 132 
and retain students from among the populations described in 133 
subparagraph (A)(i) to (A)(v), inclusive, of subdivision (3) of 134 
subsection (c) of this section; (16) a plan to share student learning 135 
practices and experiences with the local or regional board of education 136 
of the town in which the proposed charter school is to be located; and 137 
(17) in the case of an application in which the governing council of the 138 
proposed charter school intends to contract with a charter 139 
management organization for whole school management services: (A) 140 
Evidence of the charter management organization's ability to (i) serve 141 
student populations that are similar to the student population that will 142 
be served by the proposed charter school, (ii) create strong academic 143 
outcomes for students, and (iii) successfully manage nonacademic 144 
school functions, (B) a term sheet that sets forth (i) the length of the 145 
contract for whole school management services, (ii) the roles and 146 
responsibilities of the governing council of the proposed charter 147 
school, the staff of the proposed charter school and the charter 148 
management organization, (iii) the scope of services and resources to 149 
be provided by the charter management organization, (iv) the 150 
performance evaluation measures and timelines, (v) the compensation 151 
structure, including a clear identification of all fees to be paid to the 152 
charter management organization, (vi) the methods of contract 153 
oversight and enforcement, and (vii) the conditions for renewal and 154 
termination of the contract, and (C) evidence of compliance with the 155  Substitute Bill No. 7245 
 
 
LCO    {\\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2019HB-07245-
R02-HB.docx }   
6 of 13 
 
provisions of section 10-66tt. Subject to the provisions of subsection (b) 156 
of section 10-66dd, an application may include, or a charter school may 157 
file, requests to waive provisions of the general statutes and 158 
regulations not required under sections 10-66aa to 10-66nn, inclusive, 159 
and which are within the jurisdiction of the State Board of Education.  160 
(e) An application for the establishment of a local charter school 161 
shall be submitted to the local or regional board of education of the 162 
school district in which the local charter school is to be located for 163 
approval pursuant to this subsection. The local or regional board of 164 
education shall: (1) Review the application; (2) hold a public hearing in 165 
the school district on such application; (3) survey teachers and parents 166 
in the school district to determine if there is sufficient interest in the 167 
establishment and operation of the local charter school; and (4) vote on 168 
a complete application not later than seventy-five days after the date of 169 
receipt of such application. Such board of education may approve the 170 
application by a majority vote of the members of the board present and 171 
voting at a regular or special meeting of the board called for such 172 
purpose. If the application is approved, the board shall forward the 173 
application to the State Board of Education. The State Board of 174 
Education shall vote on the application not later than sixty days after 175 
the date of receipt of such application. Subject to the provisions of 176 
subsection (c) of this section, the State Board of Education may 177 
approve the application and grant the initial certificate of approval for 178 
the charter for the local charter school or reject such application by a 179 
majority vote of the members of the state board present and voting at a 180 
regular or special meeting of the state board called for such purpose. 181 
The State Board of Education may condition granting the initial 182 
certificate of approval for the charter for the local charter school on the 183 
applicant meeting certain conditions determined by the Commissioner 184 
of Education to be necessary and may authorize the commissioner to 185 
release the initial certificate of approval for the charter when the 186 
commissioner determines such conditions are met. After an initial 187 
certificate of approval for a charter for a local charter school is deemed 188 
a charter pursuant to subdivision (2) of subsection (a) of this section, 189  Substitute Bill No. 7245 
 
 
LCO    {\\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2019HB-07245-
R02-HB.docx }   
7 of 13 
 
such charter may be valid for a period of time of up to five years. The 190 
state board may allow the applicant to delay its opening for a period of 191 
up to one school year in order for the applicant to fully prepare to 192 
provide appropriate instructional services. On and after July 1, 2015, 193 
any initial certificate of approval for a charter granted by the state 194 
board to a local charter school shall include academic and 195 
organizational performance goals, developed by the state board, that 196 
set forth the performance indicators, measures and metrics that will be 197 
used by the state board to evaluate the local charter school.  198 
(f) (1) Except as otherwise provided in subdivision (2) of this 199 
subsection, an application for the establishment of a state charter 200 
school shall be (A) submitted to the State Board of Education for 201 
approval in accordance with the provisions of this subsection, and (B) 202 
filed with the local or regional board of education in the school district 203 
in which the charter school is to be located. The state board shall: (i) 204 
Review such application; (ii) hold a public hearing on such application 205 
in the school district in which such state charter school is to be located; 206 
(iii) solicit and review comments on the application from the local or 207 
regional board of education for the school district in which such 208 
charter school is to be located and from the local or regional boards of 209 
education for school districts that are contiguous to the district in 210 
which such school is to be located; and (iv) vote on a complete 211 
application not later than ninety days after the date of receipt of such 212 
application. The State Board of Education may approve an application 213 
and grant the initial certificate of approval for the charter for the state 214 
charter school by a majority vote of the members of the state board 215 
present and voting at a regular or special meeting of the state board 216 
called for such purpose. The State Board of Education may condition 217 
granting the initial certificate of approval for the charter for the state 218 
charter school on the applicant meeting certain conditions determined 219 
by the Commissioner of Education to be necessary and may authorize 220 
the commissioner to release the initial certificate of approval for the 221 
charter when the commissioner determines such conditions are met. 222 
After an initial certificate of approval for a charter for a state charter 223  Substitute Bill No. 7245 
 
 
LCO    {\\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2019HB-07245-
R02-HB.docx }   
8 of 13 
 
school is deemed a charter pursuant to subdivision (2) of subsection (a) 224 
of this section, such charter may be valid for a period of time of up to 225 
five years. The state board may allow the applicant to delay its 226 
opening for a period of up to one school year in order for the applicant 227 
to fully prepare to provide appropriate instructional services. On and 228 
after July 1, 2015, any initial certificate of approval for a charter 229 
granted by the state board to a state charter school shall include 230 
academic and organizational performance goals, developed by the 231 
state board, that set forth the performance indicators, measures and 232 
metrics that will be used by the state board to evaluate the state charter 233 
school. 234 
(2) On and after July 1, 2012, and before July 1, 2015, the State Board 235 
of Education shall not approve more than four applications for the 236 
establishment of new state charter schools unless two of the four such 237 
applications are for the establishment of two new state charter schools 238 
whose mission, purpose and specialized focus is to provide dual 239 
language programs or other models focusing on language acquisition 240 
for English language learners. Approval of applications under this 241 
subdivision shall be in accordance with the provisions of this section. 242 
(g) Charters may be renewed, upon application, in accordance with 243 
the provisions of this section for the granting of such charters. Upon 244 
application for such renewal, the State Board of Education may 245 
commission an independent appraisal of the performance of the 246 
charter school that includes, but is not limited to, an evaluation of the 247 
school's compliance with the provisions of this section and, on and 248 
after July 1, 2015, progress in meeting the academic and organizational 249 
performance goals set forth in the charter granted to the charter school. 250 
The State Board of Education shall consider the results of any such 251 
appraisal in determining whether to renew such charter. The State 252 
Board of Education may deny an application for the renewal of a 253 
charter if (1) student progress has not been sufficiently demonstrated, 254 
as determined by the commissioner, (2) the governing council has not 255 
been sufficiently responsible for the operation of the school or has 256  Substitute Bill No. 7245 
 
 
LCO    {\\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2019HB-07245-
R02-HB.docx }   
9 of 13 
 
misused or spent public funds in a manner that is detrimental to the 257 
educational interests of the students attending the charter school, (3) 258 
the school has not been in compliance with the terms of the charter, 259 
applicable laws and regulations, (4) the efforts of the school have been 260 
insufficient to effectively attract, enroll and retain students from 261 
among the following populations: (A) Students with a history of low 262 
academic performance, (B) students who receive free or reduced 263 
priced lunches pursuant to federal law and regulations, (C) students 264 
with a history of behavioral and social difficulties, (D) students 265 
identified as requiring special education, or (E) students who are 266 
English language learners, or (5) the governing council of the state or 267 
local charter school has not provided evidence that such council has 268 
initiated substantive communication with the local or regional board of 269 
education of the town in which the state or local charter school is 270 
located to share student learning practices and experiences. If the State 271 
Board of Education does not renew a charter, it shall notify the 272 
governing council of the charter school of the reasons for such 273 
nonrenewal. On and after July 1, 2015, any charter renewed by the 274 
State Board of Education shall include academic and organizational 275 
performance goals, developed by the state board, that set forth the 276 
performance indicators, measures and metrics that will be used by the 277 
state board to evaluate the charter school. 278 
(h) The Commissioner of Education may at any time place a charter 279 
school on probation if (1) the school has failed to (A) adequately 280 
demonstrate student progress, as determined by the commissioner, (B) 281 
comply with the terms of its charter or with applicable laws and 282 
regulations, (C) achieve measurable progress in reducing racial, ethnic 283 
and economic isolation, or (D) maintain its nonsectarian status, or (2) 284 
the governing council has demonstrated an inability to provide 285 
effective leadership to oversee the operation of the charter school or 286 
has not ensured that public funds are expended prudently or in a 287 
manner required by law. If a charter school is placed on probation, the 288 
commissioner shall provide written notice to the charter school of the 289 
reasons for such placement, not later than five days after the 290  Substitute Bill No. 7245 
 
 
LCO    {\\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2019HB-07245-
R02-HB.docx }   
10 of 13 
 
placement, and shall require the charter school to file with the 291 
Department of Education a corrective action plan acceptable to the 292 
commissioner not later than thirty-five days from the date of such 293 
placement. The charter school shall implement a corrective action plan 294 
accepted by the commissioner not later than thirty days after the date 295 
of such acceptance. The commissioner may impose any additional 296 
terms of probation on the school that the commissioner deems 297 
necessary to protect the educational or financial interests of the state. 298 
The charter school shall comply with any such additional terms not 299 
later than thirty days after the date of their imposition. The 300 
commissioner shall determine the length of time of the probationary 301 
period, which may be up to one year, provided the commissioner may 302 
extend such period, for up to one additional year, if the commissioner 303 
deems it necessary. In the event that the charter school does not file or 304 
implement the corrective action plan within the required time period 305 
or does not comply with any additional terms within the required time 306 
period, the Commissioner of Education may withhold grant funds 307 
from the school until the plan is fully implemented or the school 308 
complies with the terms of probation, provided the commissioner may 309 
extend the time period for such implementation and compliance for 310 
good cause shown. Whenever a charter school is placed on probation, 311 
the commissioner shall notify the parents or guardians of students 312 
attending the school of the probationary status of the school and the 313 
reasons for such status. During the term of probation, the 314 
commissioner may require the school to file interim reports concerning 315 
any matter the commissioner deems relevant to the probationary 316 
status of the school, including financial reports or statements. No 317 
charter school on probation may increase its student enrollment or 318 
engage in the recruitment of new students without the consent of the 319 
commissioner. 320 
(i) The State Board of Education may revoke a charter if a charter 321 
school has failed to: (1) Comply with the terms of probation, including 322 
the failure to file or implement a corrective action plan; (2) 323 
demonstrate satisfactory student progress, as determined by the 324  Substitute Bill No. 7245 
 
 
LCO    {\\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2019HB-07245-
R02-HB.docx }   
11 of 13 
 
commissioner; (3) comply with the terms of its charter or applicable 325 
laws and regulations; or (4) manage its public funds in a prudent or 326 
legal manner. Unless an emergency exists, prior to revoking a charter, 327 
the State Board of Education shall provide the governing council of the 328 
charter school with a written notice of the reasons for the revocation, 329 
including the identification of specific incidents of noncompliance with 330 
the law, regulation or charter or other matters warranting revocation 331 
of the charter. The State Board of Education shall also provide the 332 
governing council with the opportunity to demonstrate compliance 333 
with all requirements for the retention of its charter by providing the 334 
State Board of Education or a subcommittee of the board, as 335 
determined by the State Board of Education, with a written or oral 336 
presentation. Such presentation shall include an opportunity for the 337 
governing council to present documentary and testimonial evidence to 338 
refute the facts cited by the State Board of Education for the proposed 339 
revocation or in justification of its activities. Such opportunity shall not 340 
constitute a contested case within the meaning of chapter 54. The State 341 
Board of Education shall determine, not later than thirty days after the 342 
date of an oral presentation or receipt of a written presentation, 343 
whether and when the charter shall be revoked and notify the 344 
governing council of the decision and the reasons therefor. A decision 345 
to revoke a charter shall not constitute a final decision for purposes of 346 
chapter 54. In the event an emergency exists in which the 347 
commissioner finds that there is imminent harm to the students 348 
attending a charter school, the State Board of Education may 349 
immediately revoke the charter of the school, provided the notice 350 
concerning the reasons for the revocation is sent to the governing 351 
council not later than ten days after the date of revocation and the 352 
governing council is provided an opportunity to make a presentation 353 
to the board not later than twenty days from the date of such notice. 354 
(j) Any member of the armed forces, as defined in subsection (a) of 355 
section 27-103, who is both a nonresident of this state and the parent or 356 
guardian of a nonresident student, shall be allowed to participate in an 357 
enrollment lottery described in subdivision (8) of subsection (d) of this 358  Substitute Bill No. 7245 
 
 
LCO    {\\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2019HB-07245-
R02-HB.docx }   
12 of 13 
 
section for the purposes of enrolling such student in any charter school 359 
in this state, provided (A) such member and such student will move to 360 
and establish residence in this state prior to the beginning of the school 361 
year for which enrollment is sought, as a result of such member's 362 
service in the armed forces, and (B) such member gives such charter 363 
school a copy of the member's military orders and written notice of his 364 
or her intention to move to and reside in this state with such student. 365 
[(j)] (k) (1) The governing council of a state or local charter school 366 
may apply to the State Board of Education for a waiver of the 367 
requirements of the enrollment lottery described in subdivision (8) of 368 
subsection (d) of this section, provided such state or local charter 369 
school has as its primary purpose the establishment of education 370 
programs designed to serve one or more of the following populations: 371 
(A) Students with a history of behavioral and social difficulties, (B) 372 
students identified as requiring special education, (C) students who 373 
are English language learners, or (D) students of a single gender. 374 
(2) An enrollment lottery described in subdivision (8) of subsection 375 
(d) of this section shall not be held for a local charter school that is 376 
established at a school that is among the schools with a percentage 377 
equal to or less than five per cent when all schools are ranked highest 378 
to lowest in accountability index scores, as defined in section 10-223e. 379 
Sec. 2. Section 10-264l of the general statutes is amended by adding 380 
subsection (q) as follows (Effective October 1, 2019): 381 
(NEW) (q) Any member of the armed forces, as defined in 382 
subsection (a) of section 27-103, who is both a nonresident of this state 383 
and the parent or guardian of a nonresident student, shall be allowed 384 
to participate in an enrollment lottery described in subdivision (3) of 385 
subsection (m) of this section and subsection (a) of section 10-264o for 386 
the purpose of enrolling such student in any interdistrict magnet 387 
school in this state, provided (1) such member and such student will 388 
move to and establish residence in this state prior to the beginning of 389 
the school year for which enrollment is sought, as a result of such 390  Substitute Bill No. 7245 
 
 
LCO    {\\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2019HB-07245-
R02-HB.docx }   
13 of 13 
 
member's service in the armed forces, and (2) such member gives such 391 
interdistrict magnet school a copy of the member's military orders and 392 
written notice of his or her intention to move to and reside in this state 393 
with such student. 394 
This act shall take effect as follows and shall amend the following 
sections: 
 
Section 1 October 1, 2019 10-66bb 
Sec. 2 October 1, 2019 10-264l 
 
 
VA Joint Favorable Subst.  
ED Joint Favorable