Requesting The Office Of Information Practices To Convene A Working Group To Develop Recommendations For The Treatment Of Deliberative And Pre-decisional Agency Records.
Impact
The resolution seeks to amend the existing Uniform Information Practices Act (UIPA) by considering the introduction of new statutory standards for agency records. By examining the balance of interests involved, the working group is tasked with reviewing current practices not only in Hawaii but also in other jurisdictions. This examination aims to address how deliberative processes can be managed without compromising public transparency and access to information.
Summary
SCR192 is a concurrent resolution from the 31st Legislature of Hawaii that requests the Office of Information Practices (OIP) to convene a working group focused on developing recommendations regarding the treatment of deliberative and pre-decisional agency records. The resolution arises from concerns about the potential overreach of the deliberative process privilege, which has been criticized for enabling government agencies to withhold information that should be accessible to the public. The aim is to strike a balance between ensuring effective government decision-making and maintaining transparency.
Sentiment
The sentiment around SCR192 reflects a recognition of the need for reform in how agency deliberations are handled. While proponents support a structured approach to reconciliation between transparency and deliberative freedom, critics emphasize the risk that excessive privileges may lead to a lack of accountability and public oversight. Thus, the discussion encapsulates a broader debate over the handling of governmental processes and the public's right to know.
Contention
Notable points of contention surrounding SCR192 involve the complexity of finding a statutory solution that satisfies both government operations and public interest. Critics have pointed out the historical abuse of the deliberative process privilege, suggesting that any new recommendations must ensure that agencies cannot arbitrarily deny access to information. The structure of the working group itself—with representatives of both public interest groups and government agencies—illustrates an effort to mediate these competing interests, although achieving consensus may prove challenging.
Same As
Requesting The Office Of Information Practices To Convene A Working Group To Develop A Recommendation For A Statutory Standard For The Treatment Of Deliberative And Predecisional Agency Records.
Same As
Requesting The Office Of Information Practices To Convene A Working Group To Develop Recommendations For The Treatment Of Deliberative And Pre-decisional Agency Records.
Requesting The Office Of Planning And Sustainable Development To Convene A Working Group To Develop Recommendations To Expand Blue Carbon Initiatives In The State.
Requesting The Office Of Planning And Sustainable Development To Convene A Working Group To Develop Recommendations To Expand Blue Carbon Initiatives In The State.
Requesting The Office Of Planning And Sustainable Development To Convene A Working Group To Develop Recommendations To Expand Blue Carbon Initiatives In The State.
Requesting The Office Of Planning And Sustainable Development To Convene A Working Group To Develop Recommendations To Expand Blue Carbon Initiatives In The State.
Requesting The Department Of Health's State Health Planning And Development Agency To Convene A Health Data Sharing Working Group To Accelerate And Expand The Sharing Of Real Time Health Information Among Health Care Entities And Government Agencies In The State.
Requesting The State Health Planning And Development Agency To Convene A Health Information Data Sharing Working Group To Collaborate And Establish The Framework And Standards For Future Health Information Data Sharing Legislation.
Requesting The State Health Planning And Development Agency To Convene A Health Information Data Sharing Working Group To Collaborate And Establish The Framework And Standards For Future Health Information Data Sharing Legislation.
Requesting The Department Of Human Resource Development To Convene A Working Group To Help State Department Managers Foster Thriving Work Environments.
Requesting The Department Of Health's State Health Planning And Development Agency To Convene A Health Data Sharing Working Group To Accelerate And Expand The Sharing Of Real Time Health Information Among Health Care Entities And Government Agencies In The State.
Requesting The Hawaii State Energy Office To Convene A Renewable Liquid Fuels Working Group To Study Local Production, Development, And Incentives For Renewable Liquid Fuels.
A bill for an act relating to actions regarding the economic interest of enterprise shareholders and participants in and beneficiaries of public pension benefit plans, and providing penalties.
A bill for an act relating to actions regarding the economic interest of enterprise shareholders and participants in and beneficiaries of public pension benefit plans, and providing penalties.