Louisiana 2012 Regular Session

Louisiana Senate Bill SB687

Introduced
4/3/12  
Refer
4/3/12  
Report Pass
5/1/12  

Caption

Provides relative to the sentencing guidelines for first and subsequent offense DWI. (gov sig) (EG INCREASE GF EX See Note)

Impact

The legislation aims to enhance public safety by discouraging impaired driving through strict penalties, which may lead to a reduction in drunk driving incidents. By instituting mandatory health evaluations and treatment for offenders, it seeks not only to punish but also to address underlying substance use disorders. The financial burden of these evaluations and treatments will fall on the offenders, unless they are deemed indigent, potentially raising concerns about accessibility to necessary recovery resources.

Summary

Senate Bill 687 provides comprehensive amendments to the existing laws regarding the offenses related to operating a vehicle while intoxicated (DWI). The bill introduces stricter penalties for first and subsequent offenses, including mandatory fines and imprisonment terms that must be served without the possibility of parole or probation under specified conditions. Notably, for first convictions, offenders with a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) over certain thresholds will face higher fines and longer mandatory imprisonment periods.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding SB 687 appears to be mixed amongst lawmakers and the public. Proponents argue that the bill is a necessary step to combat the ongoing issue of drunk driving and advocate for stricter penalties to deter habitual offenders. Conversely, there are concerns raised by certain advocates about the harshness of the penalties and the obligation for offenders to pay for evaluations and treatments, which may disproportionately affect lower-income individuals.

Contention

Key points of contention include the mandatory nature of treatment for offenders and the financial implications associated with it. Additionally, discussions highlight concerns regarding the potential overreach of legal penalties, particularly the argument that the bill may not adequately consider the rehabilitative needs of offenders versus punitive measures. The balance between public safety, financial responsibilities, and rehabilitation continues to be a significant area of debate around this legislation.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Similar Bills

LA SB533

Provides relative to substance abuse evaluations of persons convicted of DWI.

LA SB755

Requires the mandatory completion of a court-approved substance abuse program as part of the penalty for operating a vehicle while intoxicated. (8/15/10) (OR SEE FISC NOTE GF EX)

LA HB799

Provides for required evaluation and treatment for first and second DWI offenders

LA SB277

Provides for changes to DWI laws. (1/1/15)

LA SB139

Provides relative to criminal justice. (11/1/17) (EN DECREASE GF EX See Note)

KS HB2010

Senate Substitute for HB 2010 by Committee on Judiciary - Updating a statutory cross reference to provide proper jury instruction in cases when a defendant lacks the required mental state to commit a crime; increasing the penalty for certain violations of criminal discharge of a firearm when a person was present in the dwelling, building, structure or motor vehicle at which the offender discharged a firearm; enacting the reduce armed violence act to increase the criminal penalties for certain violations of criminal possession of a weapon by a convicted felon that involve firearms; providing that the service of postrelease supervision period shall not toll except as otherwise provided by law; and allowing certain nondrug offenders to participate in a certified drug abuse treatment program.

LA HB27

Amends penalties for cruelty to juveniles when the offense involves exposure of children to controlled dangerous substances (OR INCREASE GF EX See Note)

KS SB239

Creating a special sentencing rule to add 100 months to a sentence for distribution of a controlled substance when the substance involved is fentanyl and the distribution causes the death of a child.