Louisiana House Bill HCR147

Louisiana 2010 Regular Session

• Introduced: 5/3/10
• Engrossed: 5/4/10
• Report Pass: 6/7/10
• Passed: 6/9/10

Caption

Requests BESE to study the rate of suspensions and expulsions in La. and to submit a written report of findings and recommendations to the House and Senate education committees prior to the 2011 R.S.

Impact

By requiring BESE to conduct a comprehensive study and report by a specified deadline, HCR147 intends to catalyze legislative action aimed at reforming disciplinary procedures within Louisiana's school systems. This move emphasizes the necessity of understanding the underlying issues that lead to such high rates of suspensions and expulsions. The bill aims to ensure that all students are afforded equal educational opportunities, following the state’s constitutional duty to provide humane and just learning environments.

Summary

House Concurrent Resolution 147 urges the State Board of Elementary and Secondary Education (BESE) to study the high rates of student suspensions and expulsions in Louisiana. The resolution acknowledges concerns regarding the serious implications of these disciplinary actions on students’ educational outcomes and future opportunities. The bill seeks to highlight the need for thorough research and analysis regarding the impact of suspension and expulsion practices on the student population, particularly in light of alarming statistics indicating Louisiana's expulsion and suspension rates exceed national averages significantly.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding HCR147 appears to be largely supportive among educators and advocates for children's rights. Many recognize the necessity for reform in school discipline policies, believing that a deeper understanding of these issues could lead to more equitable educational practices. However, some may express concern regarding the implementation of findings, as it requires a commitment to change from various educational stakeholders, potentially creating tensions amidst calls for reform and traditional practices.

Contention

Notably, the discussions might revolve around points of contention regarding how to best address the high suspension and expulsion rates. Stakeholders may debate the balance between maintaining school discipline and ensuring students are not disproportionately punished, particularly within marginalized communities. Additionally, there may be concerns about administrative support for recommended changes, funding for programs that promote alternative discipline methods, and the need for training educators on effective classroom management and restorative practices.