New Jersey 2024-2025 Regular Session

New Jersey Assembly Bill A5558

Introduced
4/10/25  

Caption

Establishes certain requirements for asserting cause of action under consumer fraud act and limits awarding of attorneys' fees.

Impact

The immediate impact of A5558 upon enactment would be a significant alteration in how consumer fraud claims are handled within New Jersey. By requiring that claimants demonstrate actual harm with definitive and objective evidence, the bill aims to prevent claims based on mere technical violations of the CFA where actual consumer fraud has not occurred. This aspect of the bill is seen as an effort to temper litigation against businesses, as it could deter claims that lack substantive basis and therefore preserve judicial resources.

Summary

Assembly Bill A5558, introduced in New Jersey, focuses on amending the state's Consumer Fraud Act (CFA) by establishing specific criteria required to assert a personal cause of action under the act. Importantly, the bill mandates that an individual claiming damages must demonstrate that they acted as a reasonable consumer would, and that the alleged unlawful acts would have misled a reasonable person in a similar position. This introduces a more rigorous standard for consumers filing claims, which could potentially limit frivolous lawsuits.

Contention

While the sponsors of A5558 argue that the measures will protect businesses and reduce unnecessary legal actions, critics may contend that the bill undermines consumer protections. Opponents might argue that this creates barriers for consumers, making it more challenging for them to seek redress for legitimate grievances, particularly when corporations may have more resources to defend against such claims. As a result, there is a concern that the bill could disproportionately favor business interests over consumer rights.

Notable_points

The bill also specifies that any awarded attorneys' fees should reasonably match the monetary judgment, or reflect the time spent when equitable relief is granted. This provision is intended to curtail excessive legal costs in consumer litigation, reflecting the broader intent of the bill to reform the litigation landscape surrounding consumer fraud in New Jersey. A5558 is expected to affect not just consumers, but also ensure that legal frameworks afford substantial consideration to the implications of these types of fraud claims against businesses.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

NJ A2084

Revises individual cause of action under consumer fraud act.

NJ A2659

Revises individual cause of action under consumer fraud act.

NJ S699

Requires dealerships to notify buyers of recalls on used motor vehicles for sales; limits attorneys' fees in certain consumer actions.

NJ S1199

Requires dealerships to notify buyers of recalls on used motor vehicles for sales; limits attorneys' fees in certain consumer actions.

NJ S901

Updates notice requirements for actions alleging consumer fraud violations and adds indirect purchasers as parties who can receive damages for antitrust violations.

NJ A1556

Updates notice requirements for actions alleging consumer fraud violations and adds indirect purchasers as parties who can receive damages for antitrust violations.

NJ A3844

Establishes certain requirements for social media websites concerning content moderation practices; establishes cause of action against social media websites for violation of content moderation practices.

NJ S1374

Concerns certain actions brought under "Truth-in-Consumer Contract, Warranty and Notice Act."

NJ S1227

Concerns certain actions brought under "Truth-in-Consumer Contract, Warranty and Notice Act."

NJ A4738

Establishes requirements for social media companies concerning content moderation practices; establishes cause of action against social media companies for violation of content moderation practices.

Similar Bills

IL SB3671

STATES ATTY-PEACE OFCR-PRIVACY

IL SB2087

STATES ATTY-PEACE OFCR-PRIVACY

CA SB605

State attorneys and administrative law judges: compensation.

CA AB1163

Minors: power of attorney to care for a minor child.

CA SB1109

Adoption.

CA SB710

District attorneys: conflicts of interest.

CA AB2083

Public utilities: rates.

CA AB894

Attorney General: directors and employees: exemption from civil service.