New Jersey Assembly Bill ACR121

New Jersey 2022-2023 Regular Session

• Introduced: 3/7/22
• Refer: 3/7/22

Caption

Proposes amendment to Constitution permitting justices and judges to engage in extra-judicial activities for compensation as permitted by court rule.

Impact

This proposed amendment would significantly alter the current limitations imposed on judges in New Jersey. By allowing judges to earn additional income through regulated activities, it aims to adapt to contemporary practices and acknowledge the diverse contributions judges may make outside of their judicial responsibilities. However, it also raises questions about the potential impacts on judicial impartiality and the integrity of the judicial system, as outside compensation could be perceived as conflicting with a judge's primary role.

Summary

ACR121 proposes a constitutional amendment allowing State Supreme Court Justices and Superior Court Judges in New Jersey to participate in extra-judicial activities for compensation as permitted by court rule. Currently, judges are barred from engaging in the practice of law or other gainful pursuits while in office. The amendment seeks to revise this restriction, enabling judges to earn supplemental income through activities defined and regulated by the Supreme Court, provided that such compensation does not exceed 15% of their annual salary.

Contention

The discussion surrounding ACR121 may involve concerns about the appropriateness of judges engaging in outside activities for compensation. Critics might argue that allowing judges to earn additional income could undermine public trust in the judiciary, introducing a perception of bias or compromised objectivity. Supporters, on the other hand, may assert that regulated extra-judicial work can enhance the judges' expertise and serve the public while maintaining necessary ethical boundaries. Ultimately, ACR121 reflects an evolving view on the roles and limitations of judicial figures in modern society.