New York 2025-2026 Regular Session

New York Senate Bill S08391

Introduced
6/6/25  
Refer
6/6/25  

Caption

Relates to the right of publicity; amends the definitions of "deceased performer", "deceased personality" and "digital replica" in relation to the right of publicity; relates to the use of a deceased performer's digital replica without authorization by the applicable right holder.

Impact

The proposed changes in S08391 will have significant implications for various industries, particularly those involving entertainment and advertising. By mandating consent before a deceased personality's likeness can be used commercially, the bill aims to prevent unauthorized exploitation of a person's image and ensure that their heirs can benefit financially from their legacy. This change would reinforce the property rights surrounding an individual's likeness, making it transferable and ensuring heirs can manage these rights posthumously.

Summary

Bill S08391 seeks to amend the civil rights law regarding the right of publicity, specifically focusing on the posthumous rights of deceased performers. The bill updates the definitions of 'deceased performer', 'deceased personality', and 'digital replica', aiming to clarify the legal landscape surrounding the use of a deceased personality's likeness, name, or voice. This legislation intends to provide greater protection for the commercial use of a deceased individual's identity and ensure that any such use requires authorization from the right holders, which often include family members or estates.

Contention

However, the bill is not without contention. Critics argue that the definitions and scope of the term 'digital replica' raise concerns regarding artistic expressions and fair use, particularly in parody or commentary. There are fears that overregulation might create barriers for creative work that utilizes historical figures, leading to unintended consequences for freedom of expression. Additionally, some stakeholders worry that the stipulations may complicate the production of documentaries or fictional works that aim to honor these personalities, rather than exploit them.

Considerations

As the bill progresses, it is crucial for lawmakers to balance the rights of deceased personalities and their families against the interests of creators and the public. The discussion surrounding S08391 highlights the complexities of intellectual property in the digital age, where advancements in technology enable the creation of realistic representations of individuals long after their death. Stakeholders from both sides of this debate will continue to influence the legislative process as S08391 makes its way through the legislative body.

Companion Bills

NY A08882

Same As Relates to the right of publicity; amends the definitions of "deceased performer", "deceased personality" and "digital replica" in relation to the right of publicity; relates to the use of a deceased performer's digital replica without authorization by the applicable right holder.

Similar Bills

MS HB1654

Publicity rights; authorize for persons whose images are used to sell products.

MA S144

Relating to protecting the interests of minor children featured on for-profit family vlogs

MA H2170

Relating to protecting the interests of minor children featured on for-profit family vlogs

HI SR81

Encouraging The United States Congress To Pass The Nurture Originals, Foster Art, And Keep Entertainment Safe Act Of 2023 (no Fakes Act) And The No Artificial Intelligence Fake Replicas And Unauthorized Duplications Act Of 2024 (no Ai Fraud Act).

HI SCR95

Encouraging The United States Congress To Pass The Nurture Originals, Foster Art, And Keep Entertainment Safe Act Of 2023 (no Fakes Act) And The No Artificial Intelligence Fake Replicas And Unauthorized Duplications Act Of 2024 (no Ai Fraud Act).

CA AB1836

Use of likeness: digital replica.

VA SB871

Retail Sales and Use Tax; media-related exemptions, sunset.

VA HB2675

Retail Sales and Use Tax; media-related exemptions, sunset.