Texas House Bill HB4169

Texas 2019 - 86th Regular

Caption

Relating to the criminal penalties for certain criminal offenses.

Impact

The bill aims to strengthen deterrents against drug-related and property crimes, particularly in areas frequented by children, such as schools and playgrounds. By imposing increased penalties, supporters of the legislation argue that it will help curb criminal activities that could threaten the safety of minors. The changes also extend to offenses like the misuse of customer debit and credit cards, which now have defined stricter terms for unlawful acquisition or usage, thus reinforcing financial security for consumers.

Summary

House Bill 4169 focuses on enhancing criminal penalties for specific offenses, particularly those committed near schools or involving certain vulnerable populations, including minors. The bill proposes increasing the minimum terms of imprisonment by five years and doubling maximum fines if offenses are committed within 1,000 feet of schools or youth centers. Additionally, felony charges for drug-related offenses would be adjusted to reflect these new standards, emphasizing stricter regulations on controlled substances and related crimes.

Contention

Opposition to HB 4169 arises primarily from concerns regarding the overreach of punitive measures in addressing criminal behavior, particularly the potential impact on non-violent offenders and the broader implications for criminal justice equity. Critics emphasize that increased penalties may not effectively reduce crime rates and could lead to unnecessary incarceration, particularly of individuals from socio-economically disadvantaged backgrounds. Furthermore, the adjustments to the law regarding property liability in incidents involving inmate actions have raised questions about accountability and the implications for the Texas Department of Criminal Justice.