California 2019-2020 Regular Session

California Senate Bill SB890

Introduced
1/27/20  
Introduced
1/27/20  
Refer
2/6/20  

Caption

Privacy: video recording of a crime: social media.

Impact

If enacted, SB 890 could significantly alter existing laws concerning the distribution of sensitive content related to criminal acts. By imposing a strict window for content removal, it aims to empower victims by giving them control over how their experience is shared and prevents potential emotional harm from the continued availability of such content on social platforms. The bill also introduces civil penalties for non-compliance, thereby incentivizing social media companies to act swiftly in protecting victims' rights.

Summary

Senate Bill 890, introduced by Senator Pan, focuses on privacy rights regarding the dissemination of video recordings of crimes on social media platforms. The bill mandates that social media websites must remove any photographs or videos depicting a crime, uploaded by the perpetrator, within two hours of a request from the victim or the victim's family if the victim is deceased. This legislation aims to protect the privacy and dignity of crime victims, preventing further trauma from having their victimization made public without consent.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding SB 890 appears to be largely supportive, particularly among advocates for victims' rights and privacy advocates. Proponents argue that the bill is a necessary measure to ensure that victims are shielded from further public exposure and potential harassment due to the circulation of violent or distressing content. However, there may also be concerns regarding the feasibility of enforcement and the potential implications for free speech and content moderation on social media.

Contention

Key points of contention may arise concerning the enforcement mechanisms and the responsibilities placed on social media platforms. Critics might argue about the practicality of a two-hour window for content removal, as well as how social media companies will verify requests from victims and their families. Additionally, the bill's impact on the broader discourse surrounding freedom of expression and the limits of censorship on digital platforms will likely be a significant topic of debate.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Similar Bills

CA AB1950

Consumers: Internet privacy.

CA SB388

Platform companies: content management: negative externalities: report: acceptable use policy: illegal content.

CA SB538

Electronic cigarettes.

CA SB435

Civil law: personal rights: online sex trafficking: sexual photographs.

CA SB646

Civil law: personal rights: online sex trafficking: sexual photographs.

CA AB1598

Impersonation for the purpose of a sexual relationship.

CA AB1312

College Consultants Act.

CA AB1628

Social media platforms: electronic content management: controlled substances.